Nike Billboard in New York City

The future needs roots

In four years, Nike put at risk what had made the brand great. Wolfgang Jenewein explains why every AI or efficiency programme should start with one question: what must we never lose along the way?

an article by
Wolfgang Jenewein

This comment was published
on 30 October 2026 in the
news magazine FOCUS, nr. 45/2026.

 

Browse all articles

AI promises efficiency gains on an unprecedented scale. Many strategy leaders are therefore focused above all on the numbers. Nike’s decline shows what happens when a purely numbers-driven transformation hollows out the very core of a company’s success. Why decision-makers should ask not only what needs to become leaner, but above all what needs to stay.

Hardly any strategy discussion today gets by without the question: what can we automate, streamline, cut? The business case is quickly calculated, and pressure from the capital markets is everywhere. A question that is at least as important is one I rarely hear: what must we never change? How costly it can be to skip that question is shown, of all places, by a company that for decades stood for a strong culture and a strong brand.

Optimised beyond recognition

In January 2020, before the AI era, Nike appoints a new CEO. John Donahoe had led the consultancy Bain and later eBay: a man of platforms, data and online sales. His brief: bring Nike closer to its customers, with fewer retail partners and more of its own apps. Then the pandemic hits and online retail explodes. Everything seems to prove Donahoe right.

"In times of change, the efficiency lens tells us what we can cut. Culture tells us what we should protect and deliberately develop."

Donahoe keeps optimising for efficiency. For decades, Nike had developed products by sport: highly specialised, passionate teams working in close contact with athletes, runners for runners, basketball players for basketball players. This is exactly where Donahoe cuts radically. He replaces specialisation with three consumer groups: men, women, kids. By pure numbers logic, that makes sense. At the same time, he floods the market with bestsellers. New trainers that people once queued round the block for are suddenly available everywhere. In the short term, revenue rises sharply. At the end of 2021, the share price reaches an all-time high.

Then everything tips. Innovation dries up, warehouses fill up, desirability turns into mass product. The premium brand sells at a discount. Even Tiger Woods ends his partnership after 27 years. In spring 2024, Donahoe publicly blames remote working for the lack of ideas: disruptive innovation, he says, is hard to do over video calls. Yet it was he who had dismantled the very teams in which Nike’s innovation had come to life for decades.

Many employees no longer recognise their company. After announcing 1,600 job cuts, Donahoe appeals to the responsibility of 20,000 staff in a company-wide meeting. In the chat, someone writes, visible to all: ‘If you’re talking about responsibility, why don’t you cut your own salary?’ In June 2024, Nike loses around 28 billion dollars in market value in a single trading day. That autumn, Donahoe steps down.

"The greater the upheaval, the more important the answer to the question of what remains."

It would be unfair to accuse Donahoe of deliberately undermining Nike’s culture. There were good arguments for direct sales and digitalisation. But the strategy was steered by a numbers-driven logic that was blind to what had motivated employees and captivated customers at the core. The danger of this blindness: the first things to go are the cultural and human factors that never show up in any financial metric.

Looking ahead

His successor is a man Nike had sent into retirement in 2020. On his return, Elliott Hill writes to the workforce: ‘My heart never left Nike.’

Hill’s first decisions are not a new vision. They are a return to old strengths. Product teams are organised by sport again, retail partners are brought back, and ‘Just Do It’ moves back to the centre. Soon the business press is reporting that Nike finally feels like Nike again.

What surprises me most about this story: Hill is no more of a sneaker tinkerer than Donahoe. He is a sales leader, but one who spent 32 years at Nike. So continuity does not depend on a rigid love of product. It depends on whether someone at the decision-making table knows what is culturally non-negotiable.

The turnaround is far from complete. Tariffs and weak demand in China are adding to the pressure. In 2026, the share price falls to its lowest level in ten years. Hill admits openly: ‘Some things are taking longer than I’d like.’ Nike’s identity was put at risk in four years. Winning it back will take longer than two.

Change needs a promise

Why this is so has been studied by organisational researchers in a field study and an experiment. People supported change more strongly when their leaders described not only the new direction, but also what would stay the same at the organisation’s core, and the effect was strongest where uncertainty was greatest. Change threatens more than processes. It threatens our sense of who we are as an organisation. That is why one thing holds true. The greater the upheaval, the more important the answer to the question of what remains.

This is exactly the uncertainty many workforces are experiencing right now. AI is challenging roles, routines and self-images all at once. Anyone who talks only about efficiency now will lose the people who are supposed to carry the change, and with them the knowledge and cultural glue that make a company distinctive.

This does not mean companies should not change, even fundamentally. But please, along the lines of their strengths. It is not enough to bolt classic change support onto strategic decisions after the fact. After two decades of constant change, hardly anyone wants to hear change slogans anyway. Culture belongs at the table as a performance factor from the outset: as the voice that asks what role the strengths that define the company’s identity will play in the future.

Elliott Hill asked that question first after his return. Whether the answer comes in time for Nike remains open. The lesson does not. In times of change, the efficiency lens tells us what we can cut. Culture tells us what we should protect and deliberately develop.

Three questions before you reach for the red pen

If your company were to approve a major AI or efficiency programme tomorrow, ask yourself: who at the table could say what must not be lost along the way? Which distinctive strength appears in no metric, and could therefore be cut without anyone noticing? And what would happen if you introduced the next change not as an upheaval, but by starting with what everyone can continue to rely on?

A new leadership impulse every Monday

Insights and case studies like this one, plus practical inspiration for your leadership practice, land in your inbox every Monday with our "Moving Mindsets Monday" newsletter.